ARTICLES

 

Examining the ethical predisposition of the next generation of business leaders in China and the Republic of South Africa

 

 

Sam Fullerton^I; Christo Bisschoff^II; David L Moore^III

^IDepartment of Marketing, Eastern Michigan University, USA
^IIBusiness School, North-West University
^IIIDepartment of Marketing, Le Moyne College, USA

 

 

---

ABSTRACT

This study was undertaken in an effort to determine the attitudes of business students in South Africa and China toward a battery of questionable actions undertaken by anonymous business entities. In general, practices such as the outsourcing of labour and celebrity endorsements met with little opposition on the part of the students. Conversely, actions such as the shipment of unsafe products to overseas markets and a doctor smuggling a potentially beneficial (but illegal) drug across international borders in an effort to help a patient were strongly condemned. A comparison of the means of the 14 scenarios resulted in statistically significant differences for the two countries on eight of the questionable actions. In seven of the eight, the South Africans exhibited stronger opposition (or a lower level of support for) the behaviour of the organization. Furthermore, the grand means for the two countries also favored the RSA as the country with the higher ethical predisposition.

JEL: D83, 84

---

 

 

“Full text available only in PDF format”

 

 

References

1 AHMED, M.; CHUNG, K. & EICHENSEHER, J. (2003) "Business students' perceptions of ethics and moral judgment: A cross-cultural study", Journal of Business Ethics, 43: 89-102.         [ Links ]

2 ANON (2006a) "Emerging markets", World Economic Prospects Monthly Review (August): 16-17.         [ Links ]

3 ANON (2006b) "Survey: Emerging at last", The Economist, 380 (8495): 10.         [ Links ]

4 ATKINS, R.; CHUNG, J. & SCHIERITZ, M. (2007) "German plan to help boost bond markets in emerging economies", Financial Times (Feb. 5): 8.         [ Links ]

5 BATSON, A, (2006) "As China reins in piracy, some seek faster results: Firms in U.S., E.U. want officials to press Beijing for stiffer enforcement", Wall Street Journal (Nov. 27): A3.         [ Links ]

6 BERRELL, M. & WRATHALL, J. (2007) "Between Chinese culture and the rule of law", Management Research News, 30(1): 57-76.         [ Links ]

7 CHEN, R. & CHEN, C. (2005) "Chinese professional managers and the issue of ethical behaviour", Ivey Business Journal Online, (May/June): 1-5. Accessed: 25 March 2007.         [ Links ]

8 CHEUNG, W. & PRENDERGAST, G. (2006) "Buyers' perceptions of pirated products in China", Marketing Intelligence & Planning, 24(5): 446-462.         [ Links ]

9 DAILY NEWS (1997) "We're in for a tough one", (Jan. 13): 8.         [ Links ]

10 DU, L. & TANG, T. (2005) "Measurement invariance across gender and major: The love of money among students in the People's Republic of China", Journal of Business Ethics, 59: 281-293.         [ Links ]

11 ENDERLE, G. (2001) "Integrating the ethical dimension into the analytical framework for the reform of state-owned enterprises in China's socialist market economy: A proposal", Journal of Business Ethics, 30: 261-275.         [ Links ]

12 FOK, L.; HARTMAN, S. & KWONG, K, (2005) "A study of differences in business ethical values in Mainland China, the U.S. and Jamaica", Review of Business, 26(1): 21-26.         [ Links ]

13 FULLERTON, S. (1993) "The ethical predisposition of our next generation of business and community leaders", Proceedings of the Atlantic Marketing Association, Roberta Good (ed.) (March): 317-323.         [ Links ]

14 HE, Q. (1998) China's Pitfall, Mingjing Chubanche: Hong Kong.         [ Links ]

15 HOFSTEDE, G. (1980) Culture's Consequences: Comparing Values, Behaviors, Institutions, and Organizations Across Nations, Sage Publications: Beverly Hills, CA.         [ Links ]

16 HOFSTEDE, G. & BOND, M. (1988) "The Confucius connection: From cultural roots to economic growth", Organizational Dynamics, 16: 5-21.         [ Links ]

17 JACKSON, T; DESHPANDE, D.; JONES, J.; LAU, K.; MATSUNO, K.; NAKUNO, C.; PARK, H.; PIORUNOWSKA-KOKOSZKO, J.; TAKA, I. & YOSHIHARA, H. (2000) "Making ethical judgments: A cross-cultural management study", Asia Pacific Journal of Management, 17: 443-472.         [ Links ]

18 KHERA, I. (2001) "Business ethics East vs. West: Myths and realities", Journal of Business Ethics, 30(1): 29-39.         [ Links ]

19 KLEIN, S. (1999) "Marketing norms measurement: An international validation and measurement", Journal of Business Ethics, 18(1): 65-72.         [ Links ]

20 LOVETT, S.; SIMMONS, L. & KALI, R. (1999) "Guanxi versus the market: Ethics and efficiency", Journal of International Business Studies (Second Quarter), 30(2): 231-248.         [ Links ]

21 MARTA, J.; SINGHAPAKDI, A. & HIGGS-KLEYN, N. (2001) "Corporate ethical values in South Africa", Thunderbird International Ethics, 43(6): 755-772.         [ Links ]

22 MOORE, R. & RADLOFF, S. (1996) "Attitudes towards business ethics held by South African students", Journal of Business Ethics, 15(8): 863-869.         [ Links ]

23 NEALE, L. & FULLERTON, S. (2008) "Social identity theory and ethical predisposition", 33^rd Annual Macromarketing Society Conference, (June) in press.         [ Links ]

24 NORTON, L. (2007) "Doubling down on emerging markets", Barron's (Jan. 1): 87 (1), M11.         [ Links ]

25 PEDERSON, M. & WU, V. (2006), "Business integrity in China", The China Business Review (Jan/Feb): 33(1): 32-36.         [ Links ]

26 RAO, Y. & RANDALL, D. (1991) "Exploring subcultural differences in Hofstede's Value Survey: The case of the Chinese", Asia Pacific Journal of Management, 8(7): 159-173.         [ Links ]

27 ROSSOUW, G. (1994a) "Business ethics in developing countries", Journal of Business Ethics, 4(1): 43-51.         [ Links ]

28 ROSSOUW, G. (1994b) Business Ethics - A Southern African perspective, Southern Book Publishers: Midrand.         [ Links ]

29 ROSSOUW, G. (1997) "Business ethics in South Africa", Journal of Business Ethics, 16(14): 15391547.         [ Links ]

30 ROSSOUW, G. (2005) "Business ethics and corporate governance in Africa", Business and Society, 44(1): 94-106.         [ Links ]

31 ROSSOUW, G.; VAN DER WATT; A. & MALAN, D. (2002) "Corporate governance in South Africa", Journal of Business Ethics, 37(3): 289-302.         [ Links ]

32 SHAFER, W.; FUKUKAWA, K. & LEE, G. (2006) "Values and the perceived importance of ethics and social responsibility: The U.S. versus China", Journal of Business Ethics, 70: 265-284.         [ Links ]

33 SCHLENKER, B. & FORSYTH, D. (1977) "On the ethics of psychological research", Journal of Personality, 37: 225-252.         [ Links ]

34 SINGHAPAKDI, A.; HIGGS-KLEYN, N. & RAO, C. (1999) "Selected antecedents and components of ethical decision-paking process of American and South African marketers: A cross-cultural analysis", International Marketing Review, 16(6): 458-475.         [ Links ]

35 SZETO, R.; WRIGHT, P. & CHENG, E. (2006) "Business networking in the Chinese context: Its role in the formation of guanxi, social capital, and ethical foundations", Management Research News, 29(7): 425-438.         [ Links ]

36 TAM, O. (2002) "Ethical issues in the evolution of corporate governance in China", Journal of Business Ethics, 37: 303-320.         [ Links ]

37 VAN ZYL, E. & LAZENBY, K. (1999) "Ethical behaviour in the South African organizational context: Essential and workable", Journal of Business Ethics, 21(1): 15-22.         [ Links ]

38 VELASQUEZ, M. (2000) "Globalization and the future of business ethics", Business Ethics Quarterly, 10(1): 343-352.         [ Links ]

39 VITELL, S.; NWACHUKWU, S. & BARNES, J. (1993) "The effects of culture on ethical decision-making: An application of Hofstede's Typology", Journal of Business Ethics, 12: 753-760.         [ Links ]

40 VOGEL, D. (1992) "The globalization of business ethics: Why America remains distinctive", California Management Review, 35(1): 30-49.         [ Links ]

41 WHITCOMB, L.; ERDENER, C. & LI, C. (1998) "Business ethical values in China and the U.S.", Journal of Business Ethics, 17: 839-852.         [ Links ]

42 WONG, Y. & CHAN, R. (1999) "Relationship marketing in China: Guanxi, favoritism and adaptation", Journal of Business Ethics, 22(2): 107-118.         [ Links ]

43 WOODBINE, G. (2004) "Moral choice and the declining influence of traditional value orientations within the financial sector of a rapidly developing region of the People's Republic of China", Journal of Business Ethics, 55: 43-60.         [ Links ]

44 WORLD FACTBOOK (2008) http://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/docs/profileguide.html, accessed 24 February 2008.         [ Links ]

45 WRIGHT, P.; SZETO, W. & LEE, S. (2003) "Ethical perceptions in China: the reality of business ethics in an international context", Management Decision, 41(1/2): 180-189.         [ Links ]